An appeal is not a new trial in front of another court. Rather, an appeal can be a request to the same court in which you were convicted (e.g. Petition for New Trial) or it can be a request to a higher court to review a decision made in a completed California Superior Court trial or proceeding or a United States District Court trial or proceeding (Federal Crime Practice).
After a Court or jury trial or the proceeding is completed, if the defendant is unhappy with the outcome and believes an error was made that adversely affected the result, the defendant may ask the trial court judge to overturn the decision or to order a new trial. Not every error will result in the conviction being reversed or the case sent back to the lower court. There must be reversible error . This means the error was serious enough that it rendered the trial and is deemed fundamentally unfair; the Court of Appeal has the discretion to require a reversal of the conviction, modification of the lower court's Order, and/or send the case back to the Superior Court for further consideration in light of the Appellate Court's Decision.
If the judge denies the request fpr a New Trial, the losing party may file an appeal in the appropriate California Court of Appeal or United States Court of Appeals.
To begin the appeal process, a written Notice of Appeal is filed with the clerk of the court in which the proceeding took place. This is a very simple form and most often is filed by the Trial Attorney immediately after the criminal conviction is rendered. The law requires the Notice of Appeal to be filed within 60 days of the final Judgment of the Superior Court (Penal Code section 1237). The Notice does not require you to specify the legal issues, claims, errors, &/or grounds for the appeal (see below the exception to this principle). If a defendant does not file a Notice of Appeal, he must seek relief from default.
Pursuant to California Rules of Court Number 4.470 the trial judge must advise a defendant of his right of appeal if the defendant has either stood trial or had a contested probation revocation hearing. If the Superior Court Judge fails to provide this information, you may obtain relief from failing to file a timely appeal notice on the grounds you were unaware of your right to appeal. It is noteworthy, however, that the court has discretion whether to grant a defendant relief from a default so it is critical you obtain this relief immediately upon becoming aware of your right of appeal.
In addition, the Trial Attorney must advise his client as to the possible grounds for reversal or modification of the judgment . (Penal Code section 1240.1 (a). Hence, if trial counsel fails to advise the defendant of his right of appeal and the defendant fails to file a timely Notice of Appeal, we can seek relief from the court as long as our client promptly retains counsel to file an appeal (in other words, the client does not delay once he learns of his appellate rights).
If you, a close friend &/or a family member pled guilty to the charges and there was no trial by jury or judge, there are very strict rules regarding an appeal. Ordinarily, the guilty plea constitutes a "waiver" of one's right to appeal. However, there are major exceptions such as a defendant raising issues concerning the sentencing or in the case where illegally obtained evidence that is used to convict a defendant. However, in any claim of a violation of the 4th Amendment (illegally obtained evidence), the Notice of Appeal must specify the search and seizure issues that are being raised.
In specified instances where there was not a trial , Penal Code section 1237.5 requires that one file a Certificate of Probable Cause if the defendant is seeking to appeal a case after a guilty plea or plea of nolo contendere (or admitting to a violation of probation). The Superior Court Judge must follow a very liberal rule in deciding the issue regarding a Certificate of Probable Cause . The judge does not act on or issue a ruling as to whether there was an error in the proceedings. As long as the issues raised are not frivilous &/or harassing, the Superior Court must issue a Certificate of Probable Cause.When a trial court refuses to issue a certificate of probable cause, the defendant may appeal that matter by way of a petition for a writ of mandate
In criminal and juvenile cases, transcripts of the underlying proceedings are automatically prepared. The Court Reporter who was present throughout the trial prepares the "transcript" of everything that was said in all of the court hearings (this is entitled the " Reporter's Transcript "). In addition, the Superior Court Clerk prepares a binder of all of the other material and documents that were either introduced into evidence or filed in the casee (this is entitled the " Clerk's Transcript "). If there was no court reporter present in court, it is likely that the court where the case was tried instead made an audio recording that can also be turned into a Reporter's Transcript.
Both of these transcripts constitue the Record on Appeal and all of the parties will be notifed onece they have been filed with the Court of Appeal. From the date the record was filed, the defendant (now referred to as the Appellant) has a specified period of time within which to file the Appellant's Opening Brief , depending on the type of case. This "brief" is a series of written arguments that set forth the underlying facts of the case and issues raised by the appellant, including challenges to the Superior Court rulings or findings; the brief sets for the basis for reversing the lower court by reference to applicable statutes (laws) and previous case decisions. The contents of the Appellant's Opening Brief are as follows: Statement of The Case (this is the procedural history of the case), Statement of Facts (this is a detailed narrative of the underlying facts surrounding the crime), Arguement (this is the most critical part of the Brief in that the legal grounds for reversing the lower court's decision must be presented in an articulate and highly persuasive manner if there is to be a basis to win), and the Conclusion (this is a short and simple summary in which the Appellant seeks to have the Judgment reversed.
The Attorney General represents the People of The State of California on these appeals in contrast to the City Attorney or District Attorney who handled the lower court case. The Attorney General assigns a Deputy Attorney General to file the Respondent's Brief , which is their brief in response to the Appellant's Opening Brief.
The Appellant is also given the opportunity to file an Appellant's Reply Brief .
Once the briefs have been filed the case is randomly assigned to a panel of justices. Then, the justices review the briefs and a memorandum that is generally written by a staff attorney for the Court of Appeal. Thereafter, oral argument is scheduled and the justices have the opportunity to hear the Appellant's attorney argue the case and if desired ask the attorney questions related to the issues raised. After the panel of justices hears oral argument, a member of the panel prepares and files an Opinion, which is a written statement of the court's decision. Some decisions are "published" and as such become legal precedent for future cases.
Decisions of the California Court of Appeal are subject to "discretionary" review by the California Supreme Court as well as to review in the United States Supreme Court for decisions based on the U.S. Constitution and federal Statutes.
There may be any number of reasons to file an appeal of a criminal conviction. It is not uncommon for trial judges to make some errors with the exclusion &/or introduction of evidence, proper jury instructions, proper criminal procedure &/or sentencing during the course of a judge or jury trial.
A criminal appeal and/or writ of habeas corpus may be the only way to correct those errors when a defendant has been convicted of a crime. Even if there were no serious errors, such as a violation of one's Constitutional rights, a defendant may want to appeal a portion of the judgment or criminal sentence to the Court of Appeal. This is especially true where the sentence to jail or state prison is significantly harsher than it should have been. In some cases, release on bail (see below)can be approved while an appeal is pending. As noted above, if the trial judge improperly admitted certain evidence into trial, and/or refused to exclude evidence that should have been suppressed under California Law or the United States Constitution, this may be grounds for an appeal.
You should be aware there are critical "time deadlines" that apply for filing an appeal of a criminal conviction. If you miss the deadline, it will usually mean the opportunity to appeal the case has been lost. Therefore, if you are considering an appeal of a criminal conviction, it is very important to act quickly and call Spital and Associates to discuss your case.
A common request for review of a Superior Court ruling and/or decision is called a "WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS." This is a request to the Court of Appeal to issue an Order to modify a Superior Court Judge's ruling. If it is granted, the lower court is required to modify one of its orders or have a hearing regarding the same. A writ or habeas corpus also has strict filing deadlines.
If you have been wrongly convicted of a crime, proving your innocence can be difficult. At Samuel Spital & Associates, we want to be your California Criminal Appeals Attorneys and Criminal Appellate Lawyers to file a Criminal Appeal &/or Writ of Habeas Corpus in either or both the California State Court &/or Federal Court system.
We will use experienced private investigators and crime experts to prove your innocence, and our criminal defense attorneys are experienced in criminal appeals and will fight aggressively to prove you were wrongly convicted. Our founder Sam Spital and his Senior Associate Attorney (who also is a former Deputy Attorney General) have handled countless numbers of criminal appeals in all courts in the State of California, including the Court of Appeal and State Supreme Court, as well as all Federal Courts, including the US Circuit Court of Appeals and United States Supreme Court.
Remember, it is the Attorney General's Office that defends the underlying conviction when it is appealed; hence, they will have a truly formitable and relentless advocate when you retain Spital and Associates to handle your criminal appeal &/or writ of habeas corpus. If you have a question about a criminal appeal &/or writ of habeas corpus in California, whether a State of California Superior Court criminal appeal or a Federal United States criminal appeal, call us as your - -
or send an e-mail now so that we can help.
Samuel Spital & Associates
8880 Rio San Diego Drive
Suite 800
San Diego, Ca. 92108-1642
Telephone: 619-583-0350
E-mail
Banker's Hill Associate's Office
Of Counsel - Russell Babcock, Esq.
1901 First Avenue, Suite 138
San Diego, Ca. 92101
Downtown Associate's Office
Of Counsel - Bill O'Connell, Esq.
110 West C Street, Suite 1300
San Diego, Ca. 92101-3978
The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. You should consult an attorney for individual advice regarding your own situation.
Copyright © 2010 by SAMUEL SPITAL AND ASSOCIATES. All rights reserved. You may reproduce materials available at this site for your own personal use and for non-commercial distribution. All copies must include this copyright statement.